601 Flares Twitter 179 Facebook 247 Pin It Share 0 Buffer 4 Buffer 601 Flares ×

There’s a lot of debate about whether giving away your music for free is a good practice or not. Some say that it devalues your music and keeps people from taking you seriously. Some say it’s necessary to get people intrigued and listening.

This post isn’t meant to convince you of one of those opinions, but rather to show you the effects of an experiment I did a few weeks ago. I wanted to see what would happen if I made all my music name-your-price (with a $0 minimum) on my Bandcamp page for 24 hours.

The Setup

Here’s how it worked: I scheduled an email to go out to my mailing list at 1am on October 4th telling everyone that all music was name-your-price with $0 minimum and asked them to tell everyone they knew about it. I also scheduled some Twitter and Facebook updates for the same time asking people to spread the word about it for the next 24 hours. After that, I had tweets scheduled for every 2-4 hours and Facebook updates scheduled every 4-6 hours over the 24 hour period reminding them of the promotion.

The Results

Obviously one result of this is that lots more people got my music for free. They entered $0 and got everything they wanted. But some other interesting things happened.

Lots of downloads means Bandcamp popularity

Since there were so many more people downloading my music (for free or not), my albums got bumped up on many Bandcamp lists. The image below shows the best-selling ambient albums for that day/week:

As you can see, all six of my albums are at the top of that section. Awesome! Also good to see Karl Verkade there!

Being higher on lists means more new visitors

Because my music moved up on some of Bandcamp’s lists, it became more visible to others who were perusing the lists that day. Below are some screenshots from Bandcamp’s stats page for this day:

So over 100 people checked out my music as a result of the Bandcamp home page and another 50 did because of the lists like the one I mentioned above. These are people who weren’t previously connected with my music.

People actually did spread the word

I was pretty unabashed in asking people to spread the news about the “free” music for this 24 hour period. Because of this, someone took it upon themselves to post on Reddit about it. This brought in more new listeners, as evidenced by the below screenshot:

Once again, 202 new listeners just from asking people to spread the news!

People still paid for the music

Now you’re probably wondering about how this panned out in terms of money. I was anticipating a drop in revenue, because that’s usually what you expect when you start giving things away for free. But what happened was that in a single day I made more than 2x what I normally do on music sales in an ENTIRE MONTH. Yes, you read that right. More in a day than in two months of regular sales.

I don’t quite know how to explain this, but I think a lot of it is based on reciprocal generosity. People seemed to really appreciate that I did this and responded by paying more than they normally would. I was blown away by people who decided to give more for an album than it would have cost them the day before.

The most important part: connections

More money is great, but in my opinion it’s not the biggest success of this experiment.

There you can see that in one day, I added almost 450 email addresses to my mailing list. That’s 450 more direct connections that I can make in the future, and 450 more people who can spread the news when I do something like this again. This is way more exciting to me than money.


So what happened here?

  • Lots of people got my music for free
  • I made an unexpected chunk of change
  • I gained lots of new listeners and connections for future releases

To me it seems like everyone involved came out happy. There were really no costs to me for doing this experiment, rather the gains were huge. And my listeners were not taken advantage of. One final statistic and maybe a slight cost to me is that my paid download percentage went down from an average of 22% to 8%. But given everything else that happened this doesn’t bother me at all.

So what does this mean for you as an artist? That’s a little harder to say, as so much depends on what you have in place and the fact that everyone’s situation is different. Hopefully one thing this does is show you the value of experimentation. You’ve got to try some things to see what your fanbase will respond to. You’ve got to learn about them just like they’ve learned about you.

Question: Have you experimented with making your music free or name-your-price? How did it work out for you?

601 Flares Twitter 179 Facebook 247 Pin It Share 0 Buffer 4 Buffer 601 Flares ×
Did you like this post?
Then please subscribe and receive my weekly music tips and other exclusive content. You will also get a FREE COPY of my Musician's Toolkit eBook. In this I reveal EVERYTHING that I use to record, produce, and promote my music. I would love to help you grow your fan base!
Tagged with:
  • http://www.facebook.com/andythedeacon Andy Long

    Excellent experiment and what a great result!

  • http://www.facebook.com/robbieplaysgibson Robbie Austin

    I think this depends on your outreach. For you who have an established fan base already and some internet presence, this yielded positive results. I, on the other hand, have had a song up on Noise Trade for months, have promoted as much as I can with my resources and have yet to make a penny. I don’t have a band that goes out and plays that song, I don’t have a YouTube channel where I play my music and I have no pre-established fan base. So, like I said, I believe it all depends on where you are

    • http://www.andyothling.com/ Andy Othling

      Completely agreed, this is what I was getting at at the end of the article. And I know it’s a different situation, but I don’t play these songs live, and Noisetrade hasn’t worked out well at all for me either. But I haven’t spent a lot of time promoting it.

    • http://twitter.com/theonegalen Galen

      Don’t know who you are, but I’m going to go listen to your song on noisetrade.

  • http://www.facebook.com/david.christmann.7 David Christmann

    our band is giving away our first EP for free aswell on bancamp..
    we made a name your price download and even tho its free we made 60 euros yet.and keep getting more.it’s pretty cool.

    • http://www.andyothling.com/ Andy Othling

      Awesome! People will surprise you when you give them the chance to be generous!

  • Ruben cordova

    Andy, I love you man! Nicely done!

  • http://www.facebook.com/brand0nli Brandon Li

    Wow that is an amazing experience! I’m very inspired by this! When I made my first EP in my bedroom, I had a blast with it. I decided that my music is more about the message than being known, so I sent my music to as many people as I could for free! Because spreading the word of God is about the message! Thank you for spreading your message!

  • Glenn Thompson

    I’m still a newbie to the digital recording domain (read: old fart analog guy,haha). Once I have enough experience to record something I’m happy with, I’d love to go the free samples route. Maybe a free EP, and if one likes it enough you can order a full CD where the price would reflect the cost of packaging, hiring a few good players and shipping expenses. It’s a start. Thanks Andy, what you’re doing here benefits us all. You seem to be quite the selfless artist, and an intelligent and talented one at that. Well done. Looking forward….

  • http://twitter.com/DevehJ David F

    I also think that your successes from this little ‘experiment’ are due partly to the sheer quality of your music! If I listen to an album/EP/release and enjoy every single track, I’ll feel more inclined to pay more for it.

  • Billy Block

    Thanks so much for sharing this. Going to do this with our artists! Continued success.

  • Tom Sabella

    Thank you. You made me think differently about free music

  • Nick

    Isn’t this kind of the same like Radiohead did in 2007 with their In Rainbows album? Effects were the same as well, much promotion and people and the media talking about it AND a they made a bigger profit than if they had done it the “normal way”

    • http://www.andyothling.com/ Andy Othling

      Yes it is! Obviously they did it on a much bigger scale… hopefully this gives people hope that it can work on a much smaller scale too.

  • Pingback: Et si je proposais ma musique gratuitement sur le Web pendant une journée ? | Entre défenseurs du net !

  • http://www.radionowhere.net/mmm/disqus.html Mike Baker

    Hey Andy – thanks for the excellent post. 450 new subscribers? Wow…I think I’d actually kill a relative for that many new addresses. Just wondering: could you tell us approximately how many people were initially on your list to send this email out to?

  • Pingback: Digital music: An experiment in fee or free… « Transmit Promo

  • Pingback: 3 social media tips for musicians - Andy Othling

  • Pingback: xbox 360

  • Pingback: penis advantage review

  • Pingback: the truth about abs review

  • Pingback: www.qualitywebhostings.com

  • Pingback: www.bumperstickerquotes.org

  • Pingback: does penis advantage work

  • Pingback: edu link building service

  • Pingback: hostgator 1 cent

  • Pingback: win a free ipad

  • Pingback: best led tvs

  • Pingback: penis advantage review

  • Pingback: backlink service

  • Pingback: xbox giveaway

  • Pingback: kids portable dvd player

  • Pingback: truth about six pack abs review

  • Pingback: penis advantage reviews

  • Pingback: mike geary truth about abs

  • Pingback: penis advantage review

  • Pingback: Jc Ubertini

  • Pingback: Cordell Quinoes

  • Pingback: Zulma Turbiner

  • Pingback: cheap edu backlinks

  • Pingback: hostgator coupon codes

  • Pingback: how to get a free ipad

  • Pingback: best 42 inch led tv

  • Pingback: penis advantage scam

  • Pingback: quality backlinks

  • Pingback: xbox giveaway

  • Pingback: portable dvd player for kids

  • Pingback: truth about abs review

  • Pingback: does penis advantage work

  • Pingback: Verlie Chism

  • Pingback: Katheryn Silleman

  • Pingback: Deshawn Steenberg

  • Pingback: Deshawn Steenberg

  • Pingback: Katheryn Silleman

  • Pingback: Alexander Braver

  • Pingback: Jayne Ladeau

  • Pingback: Alexander Braver

  • Pingback: Emerson Chorney

  • Pingback: Mohammed Castro

  • Pingback: Stephen Degrandpre

  • Pingback: Irvin Canela

  • Pingback: Phil Yochem

  • Pingback: Roy Hequembourg

  • Pingback: In Silva

  • Pingback: Cecile Gerson

  • Pingback: Darin Wathen

  • Pingback: Emile Commins

  • Pingback: Twila Balasa

  • Pingback: Leda Tepe

  • Pingback: Willis Morre

  • Pingback: Willis Morre

  • Pingback: Deja Tuell

  • James Barrow

    Hi Andy.
    This is a great atricle – thanks.
    I have one question. You said: “One final statistic and maybe a slight cost to me is that my paid download percentage went down from an average of 22% to 8%.”
    Can you explain what you mean by your “paid downlaod average” please?
    For example, 22% of what?


    • http://www.andyothling.com/ Andy Othling

      That just means 8% of people decided to pay, even though they could get it for free.

Set your Twitter account name in your settings to use the TwitterBar Section.
601 Flares Twitter 179 Facebook 247 Pin It Share 0 Buffer 4 Buffer 601 Flares ×